Who is speaking? co-option, authority, and envisioning the nation: women and narratives of sexual violence in conflict

  • Alice Fitzsimons-Quail University of Edinburgh

Abstract


This article presents an investigation of the forces of authority and co-option surrounding the documentation of violence and specifically sexual violence against women in conflict, and examines the representation of survivors in media and academic sources. The first section focusses on the use of oral testimony in the conflicts in East Pakistan/Bangladesh in 1971 and the disintegration of Yugoslavia in the 1990s, and how survivors' narratives are interpreted and communicated. It then goes on to examine the representation of violence against women in the Bangladesh conflict in a variety of South Asian newspaper sources in the years immediately following 1971. This is then further explored in the final section where these media discourses display the co-opting of women's experiences into discourses of nation-building and state legitimacy in Bangladesh. The article concludes that the sources examined reflect a tendency for narratives of sexual violence in conflict to be co-opted or otherwise 'used' for secondary political purposes by the media, the state and even academic researchers, such that the women survivors retain little authority over the communication of their 'history' and its utilisation.



Author Biography

Alice Fitzsimons-Quail, University of Edinburgh
I am a graduate of the University of Edinburgh where I studied MA (Hons) History from 2010-2014. I am currently travelling from the UK to Ghana by bicycle.

References

Bibliography

Newspapers

The Bangladesh Observer, Jan 1971-Dec 1973.

The Bangladesh Observer Supplements, various 1971-1977.

Morning News Dacca, Jan 1971 – Dec 1972.

Lee Patterson, ‘Mass Rape in Bangladesh’, in Times of India, 1 Oct. 1972.

Harii Malik, ‘Bangla’s War Heroines’, in Times of India, 16 Apr. 1972.

A. N. M. Nurul Haque, ‘Obituary of the Observer’ in The Daily Star (Dacca, Bangladesh) 17 June. 2010. Accessed online at , (22/02/2014).

Speeches

Muhammad Ali Jinnah, speech on ‘Two Nation Theory’, Lahore, 1940. Accessed at 22/02/2014.

Primary Sources

MacKinnon, Catharine, ‘Turning Rape into Pornography: Postmodern Genocide’, in Alexandra Stiglmayer (ed) Mass Rape: The War Against Women in Bosnia-Herzegovina, (Nebraska, 1994).

Malik, Amita, The Year of the Vulture, (New Delhi, 1972).

Secondary Sources

Akman, Wavelatul, ‘Atrocities Against Humanity During the Liberation War in Bangladesh: A Case of Genocide’, Journal of Genocide Research, 4:1, (2002).

Alam, Gazi Mahabubul, Rabby, Talukder Golam, Lok, Thian Boon, Khan, Issa and Hoque, Kazi Enamul, ‘National development and student politics in Bangladesh’, African Journal of Business Management, Vol.5.15, (2011).

Allen, Beverly, Rape Warfare: The Hidden Genocide in Bosnia-Herzegovina and Croatia, (London, 1996).

Anderson, Benedict, Imagined Communities, (London, 2006).

Aspel, Joya, ‘Extremely Violent Societies: Mass Violence in the Twentieth Century World (Book Review), The Journal of Interdisciplinary History, (June 22, 2012).

Brownmiller, Susan, Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape, (London, 1975).

Chattopadhyay, Saayan, ‘Bengali Masculinity and the National Masculine: Some Conjectures for Interpretation’, South Asian Research, (2011).

Das, Charity, ‘Book Review: Samila Bose, 2011, Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 War’ Journal of South Asian Development, 8:136, (2013).

D’Costa, Bina, Nationbuilding, Gender and War Crimes in South Asia, (Abingdon, 2011).

Delanty, Gerard and Kumar, Krishnan (eds), The SAGE Handbook of Nations and Nationalism, (London, 2006).

Farzana, Fahminda, ‘An Artificial Minority: The Stateless Biharis of Bangladesh’, Journal of Muslim Affairs, 29:2, (June 2009).

Fischer, Siobhan K. ‘Occupation of the Womb: Forced Impregnation as Genocide’, Duke Law Journal, (Oct. 1996).

Gardam, Judith, ‘Women and the Law of Armed Conflict: Why the Silence?’, The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 46:1 (Jan 1997).

Garrioch, David, ‘Extremely Violent Societies: Mass Violence in the Twentieth Century World (Book Review)’, Journal of Social Science, (Sept 2012).

Gerlach, Christian, Extremely Violent Societies: Mass Violence in the Twentieth Century World, (Cambridge, 2010).

Hayden, Robert M. ‘Rape and Rape Avoidance in Ethno-Nationalist Conflicts: Sexual Violence in Liminalised States’, American Anthropologist, 102:1, (March 2000).

Hobsbawm, E.J., Nations and Nationalism Since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality, (Cambridge, 1992).

Indian Council of World Affairs, How Pakistan Violated Human Rights in Bangladesh, (New Delhi, 1972).

Islam, Kajalie Shehreen ‘Breaking Down the Birangona: Examining the (Divided) Media Discourse on the War Heroines of Bangladesh's Independence Movement’, International Journal of Communication (Online), (August 2012).

Kesić, Vesna, ‘A Response to Catharine MacKinnon’s Article “Turning Rape into Pornography: Postmodern Genocide’, Hastings Women’s Law Journal, 5:2, (1994).

Lindsey, Rose, ‘From Atrocity to Data: Historiographies of Rape in the Former Yugoslavia and the Gendering of Genocide’, Patterns of Prejudice, Vol. 36, (2002,).
Loshak, David, Pakistan Crisis, (London, 1971).

Mohaiemen, Naeem, ‘Accelerated Media and the 1971 Civil War in Bangladesh’, Economic and Political Weekly, 43:4, (2008).

Mookherjee, Nayanika, ‘The Absent Piece of Skin: Gendered, Racialised and Territorial Inscriptions of Sexual Violence During the Bangladesh War’, Modern Asian Studies, 46:6, (2012).

Quaderi, Fazlul Quader, Bangladesh Genocide and World Press, (Dacca, 1972).
Rabinow, Paul, The Foucault Reader, (London, 1986).

Ricciutella, Luciana, Miles, Angela & McFadden, Margaret H. (eds), Feminist Politics, Activism and Vision: Local and Global Challenges, (New York, 2004).

Samila Bose, Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 Bangladesh War, (London, 2011).

Saujani, Sheyfali, ‘Empathy and Authority in Oral Testimony: Feminist Debates, Multicultural Mandates, and Researching the Interviewer and her “Disagreeable” Subjects’, Histoire Sociale (Social History), 45:90, (November 2012).

Sen, Jhuma, ‘The Trial of Errors in Bangladesh: The International Crimes (Tribunal) Act and the 1971 War Crimes Trial’ Harvard Asia Quarterly, 14:3, (2012).

Snyder, Cindy S., Gabbard, Wesley J., May, J. Dean and Zukic, Nihada, ‘On the Battleground of Women’s Bodies: Mass Rape in Bosnia-Herzegovina’, Journal of Women & Social Work, 21:2, (2006).

Totten, Samuel (ed), The Plight and Fate of Women During and Following Genocide, (New Jersey, 2009).

Tumblety, Joan (ed), Memory and History: Understanding Memory as a Source and Subject, (Abingdon, 2013).

Warner, Geoffrey, ‘Nixon, Kissinger and the Breakup of Pakistan, 1971’, International Affairs, (Oct 2005).

Zaheer, Hasan, The Separation of East Pakistan: The Rise and Realisation of Bengali Muslim Nationalism, (Oxford, 1994).

Online Sources

‘Huge Bangladesh Rally Seeks Death Penalty for War Crimes’, BBC, 8 Feb. 2013. Accessed online at 22/02/2014.
Published
19-Apr-2015
How to Cite
Fitzsimons-Quail, A. (2015). Who is speaking? co-option, authority, and envisioning the nation: women and narratives of sexual violence in conflict. The South Asianist Journal, 3(2). Retrieved from http://www.southasianist.ed.ac.uk/article/view/1173